A Simple Change by Judith Miller

When Jancey's mother's health continues to decline, she and her husband decide to move back to the Amana Colonies where they grew up, back to a simpler time. Jancey agrees to go with them because she wants to be by her mother's side and cherish the time they have left, however long it may be. Jancey's boyfriend, Nathan, does not want her to go. He doesn't see the appeal in this simple life. Moving to Amana means she will have to give up teaching because women are not allowed to be teachers in Amana. How will she decide which life she is better suited for?

This was an enjoyable read. The characters were relatable, and there was enough tension and uncertainty to carry the characters through each problem that arose. I was not familiar with the Amana Colonies before reading this book, so it was interesting to learn about this group's lifestyle during this time period. It would have been helpful if the author included an author's note at the end of the book to give additional background information on this group of people or where this idea came from.

This book was reviewed for Bethany House Publishers.

The Guardian by Beverly Lewis

While housesitting for her cousin in Lancaster County, Jodi goes for a run and finds a young Amish girl alone on the road. Little Sarah speaks no English, so the two are unable to communicate, but they build an incredible bond when Jodi is able to return Sarah to her family. Jodi begins to learn why people are so drawn to the Amish, but will an outsider truly be accepted by this group?

Usually I'm a fan of the books written by Beverly Lewis, but this book did not do it for me. I liked the concept, but my background knowledge got in the way. I live in Lancaster County, so I'm surrounded by the Amish. I was a little irritated by the fascination Jodi had with the Amish family. It's so typical, and I guess that makes it realistic, but it can be frustrating for me when people flock to see the Amish. They're people. It's not like they're aliens. It's almost as though there's too much attention brought to them, and I have seen enough of that in my day to day life that it wasn't enjoyable reading about it.

The sub plots in this book were also very predictable. I did not find there to be twists and turns along the way.

The book was reviewed for Bethany House Publishers.